GT’s Sydney Sweeney Supergirl Crushes Hollywood Version on Opening Weekend
HOLLYWOOD — In what industry analysts are calling a statistically improbable development, the independently produced Supergirl film from Genesius Times, featuring Sydney Sweeney in the title role, earned an estimated $48.7 million over its three-day opening weekend, narrowly edging out the Warner Bros./DC Studios tentpole Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow starring Milly Alcock, which took in $47.2 million.
The Genesius Times release, shot on a reported budget of $14 million in Louisiana and Texas over 29 days, benefited from what distribution executives described as “curious levels of audience turnout” despite minimal marketing spend and no major studio backing. Early tracking had projected both films in the $35–42 million range, but exit polling suggested the Sweeney-led version drew stronger repeat viewings and multi-generational family audiences.
“We’re thrilled with the results,” said a visibly calm Genesius Times spokesperson. “Sydney brought a grounded, sincere performance to the role. Audiences seem to have responded to that.”
By contrast, the Hollywood production, with a budget north of $180 million before marketing, featured extensive reshoots, a reported emphasis on “modernizing” the character, and a marketing campaign heavy on social-issue tie-ins and mocking . Pre-release buzz focused on Alcock’s “fresh take,” though some theaters reported audible sighs during certain monologues.
Box office observers noted several anomalies. The Sweeney film posted unusually strong Thursday night previews and held steady through Sunday, while the studio version experienced a steeper Saturday-to-Sunday drop. Social media sentiment analysis, conducted by firms with no apparent stake in either project, showed higher “would recommend” scores for the lower-budget entry.
One anonymous theater owner in the Midwest remarked, “People came for the one with the actual flying and left smiling. The other one… they clapped politely.”
Studios have not yet issued official comments on the weekend’s outcome, though insiders say development executives are already circulating memos titled “How Did This Happen Again?” and “Reevaluate Our Supergirl Notes.”
Genesius Times has announced no immediate plans for a sequel, stating only that “the story felt complete.” Sweeney’s representatives declined to comment beyond thanking audiences “who showed up.”
Further reporting will follow as the two films continue their theatrical runs. Early second-weekend projections for the independent release remain unexpectedly stable.
About Author
